| John Jacob Shoaf (1783 - <1860) | |
| Susanna Hinkle |
| David Livengood | Fanny Shoaf |
| b. d. bur. occ. edu. rel. bp. | b. abt 1829, North Carolina d. bur. occ. edu. rel. bp. |
| Romulus Livengood Richard Livengood David Livengood Wash Livengood Sandy Livengood Martha Livengood Alice Livengood John Livengood Charles Livengood |